Reporting at a national level with the NHL is a tough job. You have to have a fundamental understanding of all 32 teams, where they're at, and what they plan on doing for the future. That said, more often than not, a lack of research beyond the surface level can lead to the Dunning-Kruger effect happening in real time.
For those unfamiliar, the Dunning-Kruger effect is that people with low knowledge on a subject will often confidently overestimate their knowledge on the topic.
One can see a perfect example of this illustrated in Adam Proteau's piece on The Hockey News about coaches on the hot seat.
The rationale behind the "hot seat" accusation
In this article, Proteau suggests that Detroit Red Wings head coach Todd McLellan is on the hot seat and at risk of losing his job. Here's what he had to say on the subject:
"McLellan has more NHL experience than virtually anyone, and he’s ranked this high in part because he has 1,274 regular-season games of experience under his belt," Proteau begins. "McLellan would be rated higher on this list if it weren’t for Detroit’s struggles since he took over the reins in December of 2024."
"The Red Wings finished sixth in the Atlantic Division in both of the past two seasons, but this year’s abysmal late-season collapse really hurts McLellan’s stock on this list. McLellan is under the gun to turn things around in Detroit, especially now that Detroit GM Steve Yzerman has been fired. "
"McLellan is a name-brand coach, but that won’t save him if the Wings don’t get into the playoffs next season."
Proteau's analysis makes sense if you're just looking at box scores and completely ignoring context. The March collapse has been going on long before McLellan entered the fold. The struggles the Red Wings face under Todd McLellan are the same they faced with Derek Lalonde and Jeff Blashill before him.
Historical precedence aside, there's also the matter of the "jerseys" and the clearly strained relationship between soon-to-be-former captain Dylan Larkin and former general manager Steve Yzerman.
To blame this March's collapse on McLellan is to completely ignore Dylan Larkin's two 5v5 points in 2026, the rash of injuries that forced J.T. Compher into the top line and, again, the historic precedent of the team falling off in March.
Why McLellan may move on eventually
If McLellan does leave the Red Wings, it won't be because he's "under the gun to turn things around in Detroit". It'll be because the new general manager likely wants to hire his guy as head coach, a trend that's existed in professional sports since the dawn of time.
Expecting McLellan to turn the Red Wings around when their top line center is projected to be Andrew Copp is putting the blame on the wrong party. Not to mention the fact that the Atlantic division is positively loaded!
Reading too much into the quotes of a national reporter like this may seem like nitpicking, but surface-level analysis like this is shallow, lazy and ignores the context of a team's situation.
Also (and this is pedantic), Steve Yzerman wasn't fired. He stepped down!
Add us as a preferred source on Google