Skip to main content

Grading the Red Wings goaltending through the first quarter of the season

Daniil Tarasov has been phenomenal in net, but John Gibson has struggled through the first quarter of the 2026-27 season.
ByTom Mitsos
Daniil Tarasov has been a bright spot for the Detroit Red Wings in net.
Daniil Tarasov has been a bright spot for the Detroit Red Wings in net. | Mark LoMoglio/GettyImages

Goaltending has been a rollercoaster for the Detroit Red Wings through the first quarter of the season.

John Gibson started the 2026-27 season as the No. 1 goalie, but it’s been abundantly clear that Daniil Tarasov has been the better goalie through the team’s first 21 games.

The stats speak for themselves.

All situations

TOI

GA

Save %

GAA

GSAA

HDSV %

xG against

John Gibson

689:21

41

0.862

3.57

-8.48

0.727

32.56

Daniil Tarasov

488:27

15

0.931

1.84

8.65

0.880

25.87

(Stats provided by Natural Stat Trick)

Gibson has another slow start

Slow starts appear to be a theme with Gibson, at least during his Red Wings tenure.

The 33-year-old struggled to begin last season, as well, posting a 4-7-1 record with a 3.59 GAA and a 0.865 save percentage through November.

Once the calendar turned to December, Gibson found his groove, notching a 19-5-1 record with a 2.06 GAA and a 0.925 save percentage through February.

Will we see the same resurgence this season? The Red Wings sure hope so.

Last season, Gibson had the excuse of acclimating to a new team after being traded to Detroit by the Anaheim Ducks, where he had spent the entirety of his career. That excuse no longer works, and he’ll have to find his game again if he wants to start most nights.

This season, there have been a handful of games where Gibson has looked below replacement level, missing key saves an average goalie would make. It’s a far cry from his hot run last season, where he stole multiple games and rocketed the Red Wings to the top of the NHL standings.

He hasn't stolen a game this season. In fact, the Red Wings have scored four or more goals in three of his four wins this season, meaning the offense does most of the heavy lifting when he secures the win.

Tarasov impresses with superb play

Nobody expected much from Tarasov this season.

Signed to a one-year deal this offseason, the 27-year-old spent four seasons in Columbus and backed up Sergei Bobrovsky for the Florida Panthers last season in a down year for the team that didn’t have Matthew Tkachuk for most of the season and Aleksander Barkov for any of it.

Tarasov was signed to start 25-30 games, give Gibson a break and provide replacement-level goaltending when Gibson wasn’t starting.

However, Tarasov has been quite impressive, making key saves that have kept games close for the Red Wings.

His first start was a 1-0 shootout loss to the Montreal Canadiens, and he followed that up five days later with a 2-1 win against the Philadelphia Flyers.

Last week, he notched his second shutout of the season in a 2-0 win against the Tampa Bay Lightning.

It remains to be seen whether Tarasov can handle full-time duties, as he has only started more than 30 games once in his career; last season with the Panthers, he posted a 3.05 GAA and a 0.895 save percentage.

But Tarasov has made the case to be the Red Wings’ starting goalie for the foreseeable future.

Postava makes first NHL start

Picking up from last season, where he overtook Sebastian Cossa as the No. 1 goalie for the Grand Rapids Griffins, Michal Postava got some NHL minutes early this season, including his first start.

He relieved Gibson on Oct. 22, allowing one goal on eight shots. Four days later, he got his first NHL start. And what a “Welcome to the NHL” moment it was, as he faced Connor McDavid, Leon Draisaitl and the powerhouse Edmonton Oilers.

No one would fault Postava if he had a bad night against two of the world's top players, but he held his own, making 24 saves on 27 shots and securing the shootout win.

It’s good to see Postava get NHL minutes early, as the Red Wings learned from their mistake when they botched Cossa’s development by not giving him any NHL minutes last season.

Postava should be on the Red Wings roster full time next season, which would give Trey Augustine the No. 1 job in Grand Rapids before he makes the leap to the NHL.

Tarasov (and Postava to a degree) has been a bright spot for the Red Wings in net, but Gibson’s slow start drags down the team’s overall goaltending grade.

Final grade: B-

Add us as a preferred source on Google