The Detroit Red Wings’ season is fading fast as we near Thanksgiving. None of the myriad issues they entered the 2026-27 season with have been resolved.
At 8-12-3, Detroit it tied seventh in the Atlantic Division and only five NHL teams have fewer than its 19 points. The team has dropped six of its past eight games and its season is going nowhere fast.
Detroit’s list of problems include:
- A rapidly approaching Dec. 1 deadline for restricted free agent defenseman Simon Edvinsson to sign a contract (whether with Detroit or a team he is traded to).
- Former captain Dylan Larkin continuing to sit out under an indefinite suspension.
- A 2023 draft that, other than seventh-round steal Emmitt Finnie, has yet to deliver any tangible benefits despite a pair of top-16 overall picks.
- Pending free agents who don’t project to have any long term future with the team after this season.
Those four problems vary in severity, though the first two represent a rapidly closing window to receive value for a coveted young defenseman and an opportunity to move on from a disgruntled ex-captain to support their current players.
To that end, here are four trades that Interim General Manager Shawn Horcoff should pursue that can potentially dig this franchise out of its current depths.
Trade 1: Simon Edvinsson and Nate Danielson to San Jose for Michael Misa and Sam Dickinson
Why Detroit should do it: The Red Wings botched the Simon Edvinsson situation from the moment they could have given him a long-term contract a year ago. Following a strong first full NHL season, Detroit could've secured a deal anytime between July 1, 2025 and prior to the start of this season. Instead, then-General Manager Steve Yzerman reportedly lowballed him with offers well below the market rate for a 23-year-old, 6'6" puck moving defenseman who can contribute physical play and solid offense.
Michael Misa was the second overall pick in the 2025 NHL Draft and is starting to develop as a skilled center, something Detroit desperately needs. Misa is already in his second NHL season and could be a rare true number one center.
Dickinson is another first-round pick (11th overall in 2024) who has already played 94 NHL games at age 20. He is still getting his footing with the steep learning curve of being an NHL defenseman, but he was originally picked where he was due to his offensive ability. He may not ever be able to replace Edvinsson, but he is showing the ability to stay in the league as a second-pairing defenseman. There's enough upside that he could become an anchor on Detroit’s defense for years to come if the team manages to secure him in the Edvinsson deal.
Danielson has failed to develop any offense to go with his responsible two-way play as the ninth overall pick in 2023, but still has an NHL future as a 3rd line, defense-oriented center who likely won’t cost much in the long term.
Why San Jose would do it: The Sharks finished four points shy of a playoff spot despite boasting one of the youngest rosters in the league last season. Despite some early season inconsistencies, they are right in the hunt for a postseason spot at the moment. With budding superstar Macklin Celebrini and several promising and productive young forwards in tow, the Sharks attempted to bolster their defense by taking on the sizable contracts of veteran blue liners like Jacob Trouba and Darnell Nurse.
That said, the Sharks rank 29th in the league in goals against and are desperately seeking a true number one defenseman. While Edvinsson was best deployed as a partner to Detroit’s stalwart Moritz Seider, the towering Swede instantly would become the Sharks’ go to blue liner. Two recent high picks, including a center like Misa, are a steep price, but they keep their own stable of draft picks in the vault for future upgrades.
Edvinsson is already at a level far beyond what Dickinson is currently providing. Danielson may yet have some amount of offense to develop in his game, but is at the very least a cheap two-way center to play responsibly in his own zone for the Sharks’ bottom-six.
Trade 2: Dylan Larkin to Utah for Caleb Desnoyers, Jack McBain and a 1st-round pick
Why Detroit should do it: While the reported Minnesota Wild offer of Danila Yurov and three first-round picks sounds tempting Yurov is not projected as better than second-line centers. The picks are likely to be in the 25-30 range should Minnesota land Larkin and use the momentum from the move to extend superstar defenseman Quinn Hughes.
There are no such things as surefire prospects, and Caleb Desnoyers is no exception. The fourth-overall pick in the 2025 NHL Draft has six points in 15 games as a true rookie in the AHL, showing he needs some developmental time adjusting from the high-scoring QMJHL he dominated. Still, snagging Desnoyers along with Misa in an Edvinsson deal would give the Red Wings two top center prospects in the 2025 Draft in an attempt to finally address what has consistently been the weak point of this organization.
While Larkin likely moves the Mammoth up the standings in a similar range to Minnesota and only provides one first round pick, the potential upside of Desnoyers outweighs anything that Yurov could offer in a return. Impact matters and Detroit needs to find impact players to climb the standings.
As far as McBain goes, he is a bottom six forward who sometimes plays center that helps offset the cap hit ($4.25 million) and doesn’t have a no movement clause yet. That said, he does starting next season as he has three more years left on his contract. At best, he may be a new Andrew Copp or Michael Rasmussen, but he can toil away at the bottom of the roster in exchange for Desnoyers and a late first round pick.
Why Utah would do it: The Mammoth have collected an embarrassment of riches in terms of young forward talent, but most of it is at the wing. With the defense led by Mikhail Sergachev, there is enough upside behind him to be set on the blue line should they find a long-term solution in net between Karel Vejmelka, former Red Wing Sebastian Cossa and prospect Michael Hrabel. Other than Logan Cooley and Vincent Trocheck, there hasn’t been a lot to be excited about at center. Second line center Barrett Hayton is bound for free agency after this season, thus creating a need for another center.
Trade John Gibson and Axel Sandin-Pellikka to New York for Braden Schneider
Why Detroit should do it: John Gibson is not long for Detroit, while Axel Sandin-Pellikka is quickly sliding down the Red Wings depth chart. With Edvinsson leaving in the San Jose deal, the Red Wings need to replace his physicality. Schneider provides that in spades, with 56 hits in 22 games. With Schneider’s ice time dropping by about two minutes per game this year, it would give him an opportunity for more consistent top-four minutes ahead of becoming a restricted free agent.
Why the Rangers would do it: John Gibson has intrigue as a rental goalie, provided he go through a similar midseason turnaround as he did around this time last season. This proposed move is entirely contingent on lightning striking twice as right now, New York is getting by just fine in the aftermath of Igor Shesterkin’s season-ending injury with rookie Dylan Garand (2.37 goals against average, .910 save percentage) and Joonas Korpisalo (1.67 goals against average, .940 save percentage in three starts) while Gibson is fighting the puck with a 3.58 goals against average and .862 save percentage.
Axel Sandin-Pellikka showed some promise last season and has a lot of NHL games under his belt already. However, his play inside the defensive zone has led to fewer and fewer minutes and stints in Grand Rapids. Even without Edvinsson around, he has only logged seven games for the Red Wings this season and averaged just 12:42 per contest when he suited up. Still, he provided a solid for a rookie 21 points in 68 games as a true NHL rookie last season.
The 16th-pick of the 2023 draft could benefit from a change of scenery and his one additional year on an entry level contract could incentivize the Rangers to seek more insurance in net while they wait out Shesterkin’s return next season. As for dealing Schneider, he is a restricted free agent after this season. New York has some cheaper defense options starting to move up their organizational depth chart who could push him out.
Trade Andrew Copp and Justin Faulk to New Jersey for Dougie Hamilton, Timo Meier and Vegas’ 2027 1st round pick
Why Detroit should do it: This one is trickier because both Hamilton and Meier have no movement clauses that could make any would-be trade dead on arrival. With no long-term deal given to Edvinsson and Larkin’s contract jettisoned, Detroit is dangerously close to going below the salary floor. The real return for the Red Wings is turning expiring deals that still have some on ice depth value into a late first round pick and potentially another expiring deal (Hamilton) for next season.
Hamilton’s best days are behind him, but he is at an age where he is likely looking for one more good contract. Going to Detroit likely puts him in a top-four role where he could still get power play time. Meijer, on the other hand, gets a change of scenery to add more winger depth. It’s entirely possible that his contract ($8.8 million cap hit for four more years after this) becomes a problem, but it is tolerable due to the oodles of cap space the Red Wings have at their disposal going forward. This deal gives Detroit playable - albeit expensive - bodies and an additional first round pick to stock up on or deal for more immediate help.
Why New Jersey would do it: From an on-ice standpoint, the players moving are essentially a lateral move for the Devils, and they deal their extra first round pick to do so. However, the Devils are pretty obviously positioning themselves to sign Quinn Hughes so he can join brothers Jack and Luke.
Copp and Faulk provide similar value to Meier and Hamilton, but both are free agents after this season. Even if the Devils were to pick up a portion of Meier’s cap hit, they still project to gain at least $16 million in cap space for the summer. The real trick that may make this a complete pipe dream is that both Hamilton and Meier have to sign off on a trade Detroit, which may in fact be a tall order. From a team value standpoint, however, this is a slam dunk for the Devils.
In the unlikely scenario that Horcoff is able to make these moves, the Red Wings would add two 2027 first-round picks, the top two centers picked in the 2025 NHL Draft, one of whom is already an NHL regular and two young NHL regular defensemen.
