Mandatory Credit: Ed Mulholland-USA TODAY Sports

A Veteran's Perspective on Military Appreciation at Hockey Games


I served in the military and I always dread veteran’s day. It makes me feel cheap. I don’t particularly like being the center of attention (off the internet at least) and to me everything always feels half-hearted. ‘Thanks for your service! Ya know, not that I actually understand what you sacrificed or anything but it’s November 11th so I’m obligated to say something” is what it always sounded like to me. It bugs me that we all seem so ready to thank veterans on this day and maybe on memorial day and the other 363 days of the year it’s back to worshipping our athletes and musicians. But there are some hockey teams that go out of their way to make sure we don’t.

I was lucky enough to get to see the Red Wings live in the playoffs last year. Game 4 against the Ducks. My dad flew me from Virginia to Detroit and we got to meet Gordie Howe at the DC airport during our layover, but that’s another story for another time. Probably the off season when we all run out of things to write about. During a TV timeout, there was a salute to the military at Joe Louis Arena. A few service members were put on the big screen, they waved and smiled, everyone stood up and cheered and clapped while some patriotic song played. I remember being really bothered by the entire thing, and not just because the two guys in front of us didn’t bother to stand up.

The Detroit Red Wings are hardly unique in this tribute to the troops or whatever a team wants to call it. I’d say most if not all teams do it, Canada too. It bothers me on an individual level because in a way, it reminds me of my own struggle. Here’s a service member, singled out, and everyone is staring at him like he’s a damn zoo animal. I’ve grown to hate it. Don’t get me wrong, I’m sure teams have nothing but good intentions when doing these things. But we all know what the road to hell is paved with.

My transition back to civilian life was a difficult one because I felt like I was alone. I went straight to college, where I was older than a significant portion of the population, and I felt like I was singled out, like no one could relate to what this transition would be like. I personally would be mortified if someone tried to make me stand up and thank me for my service in front of 18,000 at a Red Wings game (or 180 at a Blue Jackets game. ZING!) Not because they’d mean any ill harm by doing so, but because of the act of being singled out. Of being the zoo animal. “Look at him, he’s different.” Some veterans are extremely proud of their service and would be delighted to take part in something like this, and that’s fine. But I try hard to blend back in and live like it never happened.

It also bothers me because when people stand up and applaud at these salutes/tributes, I think people genuinely believe they’re doing something great for military service members or veterans. (I keep saying service members because typing ‘soliders/sailors/marines/airmen/coastgaurdsmen’ over and over would grow tiresome). And while it’s nice that you’ve stroked this person’s ego a bit, in the grand scheme of things you aren’t doing anything. It’s analogous to the person with the gas-guzzling SUV that has a yellow ribbon magnet because he/she really ‘supports’ our troops. It’s great if you want to make yourself feel better, but if you want to genuinely make an impact on a service member, it doesn’t do squat.

If you really want to put your money where your mouth is when it comes to supporting veterans and service members, give to the USO. There’s this thing called the Wounded Warrior Project, check it out. The American Red Cross does great work with the military too. As does Habitat for Humanity. Maybe I come off sounding bitter, and that’s ok. Maybe the purpose of Veteran’s Day is to make those who didn’t serve feel less guilty about those that do, and that’s important too I guess. But if you genuinely want to go about accomplishing something, wearing those hideous camouflage jerseys during warm up does not accomplish anything. Auctioning said jerseys after the game, however, and giving the money to a veterans educational fund like the Blue Jackets have become so fond of doing, does wonders.

So should we do away with the self-fellating military salutes at hockey games? Probably not, no. If we went around getting rid of things just because one person didn’t like it, we wouldn’t have a whole lot left.  And just because a team does one of these silly displays doesn’t mean they aren’t doing other things to actually help and support the military too. Homelessness, unemployment, mental health, just transitioning back to being a person again, these are all things returning veterans struggle with, and that’s the ones that didn’t suffer bodily harm during their service. My transition wasn’t easy but it was a goddamn cake walk compared to what some of these men and women go through. And there’s plenty of NHL teams and minor league teams that give generously to help ease this burden.

You may ask “But John, if you don’t want to do away with the military salutes at games, what the hell are you trying to accomplish by writing this then?” I honestly don’t know. Maybe I just wanted to provide some perspective. Maybe I just wanted to share an unpopular opinion. (The internet is great for that!) Maybe I wanted veteran’s day to mean a little more this year. But the spa across the street from my apartment complex is giving free massages to veterans today. So I guess I shouldn’t complain.


Tags: Detroit Red Wings NHL Veteran's Day

  • Aaron

    Nice piece John. I agree with pretty much everything you said. As a vet, I hate it when people try to single me out. My wife tried it at SeaWorld once. Didn’t work out so well. Most people won’t understand what you’re talking about and they will call you bitter or hateful for it. But it isn’t that. They don’t understand that we didn’t serve for the accolades or the recognition, not most of us anyways. Someone said Happy Veteran’s Day to me today. I said thanks, and she asked why I didn’t sound so happy about it. Because it isn’t a happy day. It is a somber day, a day of reflection and being grateful for what we still have. This isn’t like Happy New Years. We don’t get presents. Heck, most people don’t even get a day off anymore. I say happy veteran’s day to those that served, because from one soldier to another, they understand what you mean. It is about the history, the heritage, and comraderie. I do appreciate when teams do stuff, however, because they have gone above and beyond recently. In Raleigh, the Canes had a great military appreciation day there, because of Bragg and Lejune and a few smaller bases. They truly respect and observe what the servicemen do. And out here in San Jose, the Sharks do a tremendous job. Brent Burns and his Burnzie Battalion is a great charity he takes part in, and all the bike rides he takes part in. those are the things that count. I’m glad they do it and it isn’t just lipservice for them. If more people took part in those things, that is how you honor servicemen.

    • Kelly Donley Shircliff

      John and Aaron,
      I want all service personnel to know when I stand up to applaud and shout positive comments, I am doing so because it is an opportunity for me to say THANK YOU!! I am a child of a Marine whom I am deeply proud of. I along with my siblings were taught to respect the flag and the commitment made by the USA military, the history and the heritage you speak of. In addition, my family has always supported the USO, Toys for Tots (my mom was a desk clerk for the General who started the program) and visited wounded soldiers at hospitals. Thus not to toot my horn but this is to let you know/understand when many stand to applaud/cheer it’s in appreciation to go with the other work/donations we are offering in support for the freedoms you have offered us. So please be not ashamed and recognize many understand it is not a day/moment of celebration but a moment of remembrance for those who have given so selflessly for this nation we love.

  • Pingback: For Those Who Have Served, We Salute You - Chattin' Bout Jackets - Chattin' Bout Jackets

  • Dude Where’s My Freedom

    Thanks for this. As a veteran myself, I completely agree. We ARE treated like circus animals and it IS insulting, even though people have the best of intentions.

    Want to thank a veteran? Treat them like a normal human being. Because that’s all we are. Normal people who go to work and get paid. We don’t “serve” anybody. We do a job and are very well compensated for it.

    When they ask the veterans to stand, I never do. I don’t identify myself primarily by my former status as property of the US government. I’m a person, just like you. I deserve no special thanks, your taxes paid my salary, that’s thanks enough.

  • Pingback: Time To End The Losing Streak | Detroit Red Wings vs Winnipeg Jets Game Preview - Octopus Thrower

  • Pingback: Toronto Maple Leafs News & Notes: November 12, 2013 - Editor In Leaf - A Toronto Maple Leafs Fan Site - News, Blogs, Opinion and More

  • Timothy Redinger

    Great article John. I know many veterans (myself included) feel exactly the same way – where are you, your support, and the flag being flown from the front of your house the rest of the year outside of the three or four days a year (veterans day, memorial day, fourth of july, and maybe flag day). I much prefer the silent nods in my direction from other vets.